I have a 74, and had the same problem. I changed out the transfer case with a rebuilt from the graveyard. BUT... I found that the transfer case input gear was worn out. You can not buy a new one, and it is not part of the rebuilt case. They don't make them anymore. I purchased a used one from James Duff, that was like new. It's hard to tell if gears are worn out. But my input gear was worn almost sharp on the edges of the teeth. I really think all I needed was the imput gear to fit the problem, but I'm glad I replaced the case, because of all the work it was to remove and replace, which you would need to do to replace the gear.
Good luck.